Skip to main content

MEDICAL NEGLEGENCE PUT CONSUMER FORA BUSY



YEAR 2013 REVIEW

Cases related to deficiency in services by railways, airlines and automobile majors kept the various consumer fora in the country busy while they also dealt sternly with rising instances of medical negligence and "black sheep" in the health sector in 2013. Doctors and hospitals got a stern message from consumer fora, which asked the Centre and the Medical Council of India (MCI) to identify and take action against the "black sheep" in the profession who did not hesitate to put patients' lives at risk for greed. "We can only suggest to MCI to take note of the prevailing atmosphere in the medical profession and identify such black sheep as are responsible for creating an impression in the public mind that they are being milked by greedy doctors. "Government should take steps to protect patients from unscrupulous medical practitioners," the East Delhi District Consumer Forum had said while directing a city-based clinic to pay Rs 1.5 lakh to a patient for trying to extend her stay by incorrectly diagnosing her illness and advising surgery. "It has been observed these days that the medical profession is affected by greed. Hospitals and doctors don't hesitate to put patients at risk," another consumer forum had said. The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC), too, pulled up several hospitals, clinics, and doctors across the country for treating patients in a "casual" manner. In one case, it awarded compensation of Rs 38.4 lakh, the highest this year by a consumer fora, to the kin of a woman who suffered brain damage and is in a vegetative state since 1999 due to "serious deficiency in treatment" provided to her by a Hyderabad-based fertility clinic. These, however, could not measure up to the highest-ever compensation awarded in a medical negligence case in India when Supreme Court this year ordered the Kolkata-based Advance Medicare Research Institute and its three doctors to pay over Rs 11.41 crore, including interest, to a US-based Indian- origin doctor who lost his 29-year-old wife during their visit to India 15 years ago.
Railways, too, received a rap from consumer fora for discharging duties in a 'happy-go-lucky' manner and was directed by NCDRC to pay Rs 10 lakh to the kin of an elderly passenger who died due to alleged negligence and passivity of its staff on a Delhi-bound train after he was allegedly drugged and looted by three co-passengers. Besides, it was also pulled up by consumer fora for failing to stop unauthorised persons from entering a reserved coach and causing inconvenience to passengers, lack of cleanliness on trains and for misbehaviour by Railway Protection Force officials. Airlines, including national carrier Air India, too faced a hard time at consumer fora, usually for losing or failing to deliver passengers' luggage on time. Jet Airways was directed by NCDRC to pay Rs 2.45 lakh to a man for forgetting to take on board his father's coffin which he had booked to be flown from Bangalore to Port Blair for the last rites. Air India was also pulled up by the New Delhi District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum which ordered it to shell out Rs 12.24 lakh for its "shocking and improper" contention that the claim of baggage loss made by a garments exporter was fake as he had filed two such complaints in the past against another airline. Insurance firms' practice of lingering on the settlement of claims was frowned upon by consumer fora which observed that these entities were using the money legally owed to the insured for as long as they could. Consumer fora also held that a departmental circular could not modify contract conditions for an insurance policy while directing LIC to pay over Rs 6.96 lakh for deducting surrender value from a pension plan holder's investment prior to refund of her money when her policy conditions clearly stated that no such amount would be deducted. Vehicle manufacturers like Maruti and Tata, as well as premium brands like Nissan and Porsche, were also asked to pay compensation to customers for either providing defective cars or for failing to deliver the vehicle after being paid for it.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

YOGA IN MID AIR

With the stage set for International Yoga Day this Sunday, yoga asanas were performed mid-air at 35,000 feet above the sea-level, arguably the first time ever! The asanas called Upayoga or useful yoga were performed as a trial-run aboard the Delhi-Guwahati and Guwahati-Delhi flights of budget airline SpiceJet with over 180 passengers and crew. The Gurgaon-based carrier has teamed up with Isha Foundation of Sadhguru to conduct mid-air yoga sessions on its select Boeing flights on Sunday, which is being observed as International Yoga Day. Talking about the yogic postures demonstrated, Gita, a teacher with the Isha Foundation said the session was designed to reduce stress for passengers who travel long hours. "These are safe, simple postures which can be done by anyone, and can be practiced anytime and anywhere. They help in relieving stress accumulated in the upper neck and spine region," Gita told PTI. The passengers on board, who had no clue about the onboard yoga demonstr...
Post a Comment
Read more
BULLION ASSOCIATION SUPPORTS MODI The Bombay Bullion Association Ltd (BBA), the apex body of bullion and jewellery bodies in the country, has announced its support for Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi as BJP's prime ministerial candidate. BBA president Mohit Kamboj along with some others joined BJP in the presence of senior party leader Gopinath Munde here yesterday. BBA had extended its support to Modi as the UPA government had brought about a "policy paralysis" in the economy, Kamboj said. "There are over 50 lakh workers associated with the bullion and gold industry, which has been facing the brunt of the current policies of the UPA government. "We at BBA strongly believe that a Modi-led NDA government would normalise the industry by introducing friendly policies," he added. Members of Bharat Diamond Bourse have said they will host Modi at a function at Bandra-Kurla Complex here on Sept. 30. BJP president Rajnath Singh had last ...
Post a Comment
Read more

WHY RAHUL SO SARCASTIC...?

Commerce Minister Nirmala Sitharaman today said Congress Vice President Rahul Gandhi should come up with "substantive arguments" to criticise the government's Make In India programme rather than ridiculing its logo. "Demagoguery may be good in election campaigns, but when you are in Parliament, we expect you to come up with concrete criticisms for which we will give reply. But to throw something like this may amuse some members, but overall it just projects the leader as not having gone into greater details," she told PTI. She was responding to the remarks of Gandhi who ridiculed the lion logo of Make In India as Narendra Modi's "babbar sher". The Congress VP during a debate in Parliament had made fun of Modi's ambitious 'Make in India' programme, saying Prime Minister has "created a babbar sher' (Asiatic Lion)" in which "clock and wheels are seen moving". Sitharaman said it was saddening that the vice preside...
Post a Comment
Read more